DRAFT REDISTRICTING PLANS REVIEWED BY THE BOARD
December 7, 2021
All draft maps below move the entire Evergreen Neighborhood in the City of San José into District 1 and smooth boundaries along natural borders such as major roadways. Based on the Board discussion and direction at the November 16, 2021 (Item No. 13) meeting, the following maps will consideration by the Board of Supervisors on December 7, 2021:
- Draft Yellow Plan: First Refinement
- Draft Alpha Plan
- Draft Beta Plan
- Draft Gamma Plan
- Draft Delta Plan
- Draft Epsilon Plan
- Draft EE 2.0 First Refinement
- Draft Plan 89749
- Draft Plan 90195
Draft Yellow Plan: First Refinement
Here is a link to an enlargeable version of the map: Enlargeable Draft Yellow Plan First Refinement
Total Plan Deviation: 5.2%
# of Split Cities: 1- San José (within 5 districts)
Latino Influence District: District 2 at 47.7%
Citizen Voting Age Population: Asian-Pacific Islander Majority-minority in District 3 at 50.1
Draft Alpha Plan
Here is a link to an enlargeable version of the map: Enlargeable Draft Alpha Plan
Total Plan Deviation: 4.8%
# of Split Cities: 1- San José (within 5 districts)
Latino Influence District: District 2 at 48%
Citizen Voting Age Population: Asian-Pacific Islander Majority-minority in District 3 at 50%
- Meadowfair Neighborhood- District 2
- Lexington Hills- District 5
Draft Beta Plan
Here is a link to an enlargeable version of the map: Enlargeable Draft Beta Plan
Total Plan Deviation: 4.8%
# of Split Cities: 1- San José (within 5 districts)
Latino Influence District: District 2 at 47.4%
Citizen Voting Age Population: Asian-Pacific Islander Majority-minority in District 3 at 50%
- Meadowfair Neighborhood- District 1
DRAFT REDISTRICTING PLANS REVIEWED BY THE BOARD
December 7, 2021
Draft Gamma Plan
Here is a link to an enlargeable version of the map: Enlargeable Draft Gamma Plan
Total Plan Deviation: 4.4%
# of Split Cities: 1- San José (within 5 districts)
Latino Influence District: District 2 at 47%
Citizen Voting Age Population: Asian-Pacific Islander Majority-minority in District 3 at 50%
- Meadowfair Neighborhood- District 1
- Almaden Valley split at Almaden Expressway into District 1 and District 5
Draft Delta Plan
Here is a link to an enlargeable version of the map: Enlargeable Draft Delta Plan
Total Plan Deviation: 1.7%
# of Split Cities: 1- San José (within 5 districts)
Latino Influence District: District 2 at 47.7%
Citizen Voting Age Population: Asian-Pacific Islander Majority-minority in District 3 at 50.1%
- Meadowfair Neighborhood- District 2
- Lexington Hills in District 1, Los Gatos in District 4, and all of Almaden Valley in District 1
Draft Epsilon Plan
Here is a link to an enlargeable version of the map: Enlargeable Draft Epsilon Plan
Total Plan Deviation: 4.4%
# of Split Cities: 1- San José (within 5 districts)
Latino Influence District: District 2 at 47.7%
Citizen Voting Age Population: Asian-Pacific Islander Majority-minority in District 3 at 50%
- Meadowfair Neighborhood- District 2
- Los Gatos and Lexington Hills in District 5, all of Almaden Valley in District 1
DRAFT REDISTRICTING PLANS REVIEWED BY THE BOARD
December 7, 2021
Draft Plan 89749
- Total Plan Deviation: 4.70%
- API CVAP: District 3- 50.0%
- Latino Influence: District 2- 49.6%
- 2 City/CDP Splits
- East Foothills: Districts 1 and 2
- San José: All 5 Districts
- Unincorporated: All 5 Districts
- 3 COI/ Neighborhood splits or shifts
- Requires adjustments to splits
Draft Plan 90195
- Total Plan Deviation: 4.14%
- API CVAP: District 3- 50.6%
- Latino Influence: District 2- 49.5%
- 1 City/CDP Splits
- San José: All 5 Districts
- Unincorporated: All 5 Districts
- 3 COI/ Neighborhood splits or shifts
December 7, 2021 Draft Maps Comparison
| Map | Current Boundaries | 1. Yellow 1st Refinement | 2. Alpha | 3. Beta | 4. Gamma | 5. Delta | 6. Epsilon | 7. EE 2.0 1st Refinement | 8. 89749 | 9. 90195 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Total Plan Deviation | 17.20% | 5.2% | 4.8% | 4.8% | 4.4% | 1.7% | 4.4% | 1.2% | 4.7% | 4.1% |
| Majority-minority API District (CVAP) | District 3 (52.3%) | District 3 (50.1%) | District 3 (50%) | District 3 (50%) | District 3 (50%) | District 3 (50.1%) | District 3 (50%) | District 3 (50%) | District 3 (50%) | District 3 (50.6%) |
| Latino Influence District (% of Population) | District 2 (50.9%) | District 2 (47.7%) | District 2 (48%) | District 2 (47.4%) | District 2 (47%) | District 2 (47.7%) | District 2 (47.7%) | District 2 (49.0%) | District 2 (49.6%) | District 2 (49.5%) |
| Split Cities | San Jose and Sunnyvale | San Jose | San Jose | San Jose | San Jose | San Jose | San Jose | San Jose | San Jose | San Jose |
| # of Districts for San Jose | 5 | 5 | 5 | 5 | 5 | 5 | 5 | 5 | 5 | 5 |
| Almaden Valley | District 1 | District 5 | District 5 | District 1 | Split 2 Districts: West- District 5 and East- District 1 | District 1 | District 1 | District 1 | District 5 | District 5 |
| Alum Rock & East Foothills | Split 2 Districts: District 2 (Alum Rock) and District 3 (East Foothills) | District 2, with small Portion in District 3 | District 2 | District 2 | District 2 | District 2 | Split 2 Districts: Districts 2 and 3 | District 2 | Split 2 Districts: Districts 2 and 3 | District 2 |
| Cambrian Park* | District 4 | District 4 | District 4 | District 4 | District 4 | District 4 | District 4 | District 4 | District 1 | District 1 |
| Communications Hill | District 2 | District 2 | District 2 | District 2 | District 2 | District 2 | District 2 | District 2 | District 2 | District 2 |
| Current District 4 | District 4 | District 4 | Mainly District 4 | Mainly District 4 | Mainly District 4 | District 4 and Some District 5 | Mainly District 4 with some Districts 2 and 5 | District 4 | Mainly District 4 with some District 1 | Mainly District 4 with some District 1 |
| Diridon Station | District 4 | Split 2 Districts: West- District 4 , East- District 2 | Split 2 Districts: West- District 4 , East- District 2 | Split 2 Districts: West- District 4 , East- District 2 | Split 2 Districts: West- District 4 , East- District 2 | Split 2 Districts: West- District 4 , East- District 2 | District 4 | District 4 | Split 2 Districts: West- District 4 , East- District 2 | Split 2 Districts: West- District 4 , East- District 2 |
| Evergreen | District 3 | Districts 1 and 3 | District 1 | District 1 | District 1 | District 1 | Districts 1 | District 1 | District 1 | District 1 |
| Lexington Hills* | District 1 | District 1 | District 5 | District 5 | District 5 | District 5 | District 5 | District 1 | District 5 | District 5 |
| Los Gatos | District 1 | District 5, Small Portion District 1 | District 5 | District 5 | District 5 | District 4 | District 5 | District 1 | District 5 | District 5 |
| Meadowfair* | District 2 | District 2 | District 2 | District 1 | District 1 | District 2 | District 2 | District 2 | District 2 | District 2 |
| Reid-Hillview | Districts 2 and 3 | District 2 | District 2 | District 2 | District 2 | District 2 | District 2 | District 2 | District 2 | District 2 |
| San Jose City Council District 1* | District 4 | District 4 | Majority District 4 | Majority District 4 | Majority District 4 | Split 2 Districts: Districts 4 and 5 | Split 2 Districts: Districts 4 and 5 | Split 2 Districts: Districts 4 and 5 | District 4 | District 4 |
| Seven Trees | District 2 | District 2 | District 2 | District 2 | District 2 | District 2 | District 2 | District 2 | District 2 | District 2 |
| Sunnyvale | Districts 3 and 5 | District 3, Small Portion District 5 | District 3 | District 3 | District 3 | District 3 | District 3 | District 3 | District 3 | District 3 |
| Western Cities | Split 3 Districts: District 1 (Los Gatos, Monte Sereno), District 3 (1/2 Sunnyvale), District 5 (1/2 Sunnyvale, Cupertino, Mountain View, Palo Alto, Saratoga) | Split 2 Districts: District 3 (Sunnyvale) and District 5 (Cupertino, Los Gatos, Monte Sereno, Palo Alto, Saratoga) | Split 2 Districts: District 3 (Sunnyvale) and District 5 (Cupertino, Los Gatos, Monte Sereno, Palo Alto, Saratoga) | Split 2 Districts: District 3 (Sunnyvale) and District 5 (Cupertino, Los Gatos, Monte Sereno, Palo Alto, Saratoga) | Split 2 Districts: District 3 (Sunnyvale) and District 5 (Cupertino, Los Gatos, Monte Sereno, Palo Alto, Saratoga) | Split 3 Districts: District 3 (Sunnyvale), District 4 (Los Gatos) and District 5 (Cupertino, Palo Alto, Mountain View, Saratoga) | Split 2 Districts: District 3 (Sunnyvale) and District 5 (Cupertino, Los Gatos, Monte Sereno, Palo Alto, Saratoga) | Split 3 Districts: District 1 (Los Gatos, Monte Sereno), District 3 (Sunnyvale) and District 5 (Cupertino, Palo Alto, Mountain View, Saratoga) | Split 2 Districts: District 3 (Sunnyvale) and District 5 (Cupertino, Los Gatos, Monte Sereno, Palo Alto, Saratoga) | Split 2 Districts: District 3 (Sunnyvale) and District 5 (Cupertino, Los Gatos, Monte Sereno, Palo Alto, Saratoga) |
| Willow Glen | District 4 at Bird Ave | District 4 at Bird Ave | District 4 at Bird & Lincoln Ave | District 4 at Bird & Lincoln Ave | District 4 at Bird & Lincoln Ave | District 4 at Bird & Lincoln Ave | District 4 at Bird Ave and Minnesota Ave | District 4 at CA 87 | District 4 at Bird Ave and Guadalupe River | District 4 at Bird Ave |
*additional characteristics added based on the 11/16 BOS direction
Bold fields are to highlight key characteristics
DRAFT REDISTRICTING PLANS REVIEWED BY THE BOARD
November 16, 2021
Based on the Board discussion and direction at the November 2, 2021 (Item No. 4) meeting, the following maps will consideration by the Board of Supervisors on November 16, 2021:
- Draft Yellow Plan
- Draft Purple Plan
- Draft EE 2.0 Plan
Draft Map: Yellow Plan
The Draft Yellow Plan originated from the Unity Mapping Table, who assembled a coalition of organizations and submitted a letter (COI No. 51) and presented to the 2021 Advisory Redistricting Commission on October 20, 2021 (COI No. 108). The Coalition provided information and met with Redistricting Partners to have their proposal developed in Maptitude for continued analysis and adjustments. The Commission recommended this map to the Board on November 2, 20201 based on the minority-representation organizations that contributed to the map’s development. Here is a link to an enlargeable version of the map: Enlargeable Draft Yellow Plan
Draft Map: Purple Plan
The Draft Purple Plan originated from maps developed by Commissioners after the first few meetings with communities of interest testimony. Additional versions were submitted and refined after subsequent presentations. Members of the community also began to create adaptations based on the original submissions. Here is a link to an enlargeable version of the map: Enlargeable Draft Purple Plan
Draft Map: EE 2.0 Plan
The Draft Purple Plan originated from maps developed by Commissioners after the first few meetings with communities of interest testimony. Additional versions were submitted and refined after subsequent presentations. Members of the community also began to create adaptations based on the original submissions. Here is a link to an enlargeable version of the map: Enlargeable Draft Purple Plan
DRAFT REDISTRICTING PLANS REVIEWED BY THE BOARD
November 16, 2021
Based on Board direction and discussion, Administration worked with Redistricting Partners to reduce deviations and to amend district boundaries of the three maps above to meet state and federal requirements. To implement the Board's direction, boundaries were adjusted as recommended during public communities of interest testimony, to reflect San José neighborhood boundaries, and to follow natural boundaries such as major roadways.
Draft Yellow Plan: First Refinement
Refinements to the Draft Yellow Plan include reducing the proposed size of District 5. This was achieved by moving the boundary between Districts 1 and 5 north, but Los Gatos and Almaden Valley remained with District 5. Many changes were made to communities of interest to unify them with the districts with similar demographic factors, as conveyed during communities of interest testimony to the 2021 Advisory Redistricting Commission and during the November 2, 2021 special joint meeting of the Commission and the Board.
Draft Purple Plan: First Refinement
The Draft Purple Plan has a low total plan deviation, followed natural boundaries, and incorporated communities of interest testimony, limiting adjustments that could be made without splitting cities or communities of interest.
Draft EE 2.0 Plan: First Refinement
Refinements to the EE 2.0 map smoothed out the southern boundaries of the proposed Districts 2 and 4 to follow major roadways and extends the proposed boundary for Districts 3 and 4 to the west of the Norman Y. Mineta San José International Airport.
November 16, 2021 Draft Maps Comparison
| Map | Current Boundaries | Yellow | Yellow 1st Refinement | Purple | Purple 1st Refinement | EE 2.0 | EE 2.0 1st Refinement |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Total Plan Deviation | 17.20% | 7.2% | 5.2% | 2.6% | 2.9% | 3.6% | 1.2% |
| Majority-minority API District (CVAP) | District 3 (52.3%) | District 3 (50.1%) | District 3 (50.1%) | District 3 (50.1%) | District 3 (50.1%) | District 3 (50.2%) | District 3 (50.0%) |
| Latino Influence District (% of Population) | District 2 (50.9%) | District 2 (49.7%) | District 2 (47.7%) | District 2 (44.5%) | District 2 (44.6%) | District 2 (49.2%) | District 2 (49.0%) |
| Split Cities | San Jose and Sunnyvale | San Jose | San Jose | San Jose | San Jose | San Jose | San Jose |
| # of Districts for San Jose | 5 | 5 | 5 | 5 | 5 | 5 | 5 |
| Almaden Valley | District 1 | District 5 | District 5 | District 1 | District 1 | District 1 | District 1 |
| Alum Rock & East Foothills | Split 2 Districts: District 2 (Alum Rock) and District 3 (East Foothills) | District 2 | District 2 | District 2 | District 2 | District 2 | District 2 |
| Communication Hill | District 2 | District 1 | District 2 | District 2 | District 2 | District 2 | District 2 |
| Current District 4 | District 4 | Split 2 Districts: District 1 (Cambrian Park) and District 4 (remaining areas) | District 4 | District 4 | District 4 | District 4 | District 4 |
| Diridon Station | District 4 | Split 2 Districts: West- District 4 , East- District 2 | Split 2 Districts: West- District 4 , East- District 2 | District 4 | District 4 | District 4 | District 4 |
| Evergreen | District 3 | Districts 1 and 3 | Districts 1 and 3 | District 2 | District 2 | District 1 | District 1 |
| Los Gatos | District 1 | District 5 | District 5 | District 5 | District 5 | District 1 | District 1 |
| Reid-Hillview | Districts 2 and 3 | Districts 1 and 2 | District 2 | District 2 | District 2 | District 2 | District 2 |
| Seven Trees | District 2 | District 2 | District 2 | District 1 and 2 | District 1 and 2 | District 2 | District 2 |
| Sunnyvale | Districts 3 and 5 | District 3 | District 3 | District 3 | District 3 | District 3 | District 3 |
| Western Cities | Split 3 Districts: District 1 (Los Gatos, Monte Sereno), District 3 (1/2 Sunnyvale), District 5 (1/2 Sunnyvale, Cupertino, Mountain View, Palo Alto, Saratoga) | Split 2 Districts: District 3 (Sunnyvale) and District 5 (Cupertino, Los Gatos, Monte Sereno, Palo Alto, Saratoga) | Split 2 Districts: District 3 (Sunnyvale) and District 5 (Cupertino, Los Gatos, Monte Sereno, Palo Alto, Saratoga) | Split 2 Districts: District 3 (Sunnyvale) and District 5 (Cupertino, Los Gatos, Monte Sereno, Palo Alto, Saratoga) | Split 2 Districts: District 3 (Sunnyvale) and District 5 (Cupertino, Los Gatos, Monte Sereno, Palo Alto, Saratoga) | Split 3 Districts: District 1 (Los Gatos, Monte Sereno), District 3 (Sunnyvale) and District 5 (Cupertino, Palo Alto, Mountain View, Saratoga) | Split 3 Districts: District 1 (Los Gatos, Monte Sereno), District 3 (Sunnyvale) and District 5 (Cupertino, Palo Alto, Mountain View, Saratoga) |
| Willow Glen | District 4 at Bird Ave | District 4 at Bird Ave | District 4 at Bird Ave | District 4 at CA 87 | District 4 at CA 87 | District 4 at CA 87 | District 4 at CA 87 |
DRAFT REDISTRICTING PLANS REVIEWED DURING SPECIAL JOINT MEETING
November 2, 2021
On November 2, 2021 the Board of Supervisors and the 2021 Advisory Redistricting Commission held a joint meeting to discuss new County supervisorial district boundaries. The Board voted to advance the draft yellow, purple, and EE 2.0 maps for consideration at its November 16 meeting, and the public hearing will not be heard before 2:00 pm. During the meeting, the Board reviewed the following maps:
- Draft Red Plan
- Draft Yellow Plan
- Draft Purple Plan
- Draft EE 2.0 Plan
- Draft Minimal Modification Plan
DRAFT REDISTRICTING PLANS REVIEWED BY THE 2021 ADVISORY COMMISSION
October 20, 2021
Based on the Commissioner discussion and direction at the October 13, 2021 Advisory Redistricting Commission meeting, the following maps were presented for consideration to be recommended to the Board of Supervisors:
- Commissioners Draft Plan
- Plan X2
- Plan X3
- Maptitude Unity Draft Plan
Draft Map: Commissioners Draft Plan
The Commissioners Draft Plan was developed based on DistrictR submissions 64085, 63774, and 62105 and will be reviewed by the 2021 Advisory Redistricting Commission on October 20, 2021 as part of Agenda Item 5, which will not be heard before 7:00 pm. Html file which allows for zooming in. Highlights of this plan include:
- A majority-minority Asian-Pacific Islander (API) District 3, with Sunnyvale whole within it (very similar to District 3 in Plan X3)
- The northern and southern API communities within San José not connected
- Los Gatos & Monte Sereno moved into District 4, out of the southern district
- The City of Santa Clara whole
- Total Draft Plan Deviation – 2.9%
Draft Map: Plan X2
Plan X2 was developed based on feedback from the Commission and the community and will be reviewed by the 2021 Advisory Redistricting Commission on October 20, 2021 as part of Agenda Item 5, which will not be heard before 7:00 pm. Html file which allows for zooming in. Highlights of the draft plan include:
- Los Gatos & Monte Sereno moved into District 4, out of the southern district
- San José removed from District 5 - the eastern district
- Koreatown whole with Sunnyvale
- The northern and southern API communities within San José are not connected
- District 3 reaches over into Sunnyvale to take in the API community and uses Hwy 101 as the border
- Uniting Milpitas with Berryessa in District 3
- Uniting Midtown San José into District 3
- Uniting Downtown San José in District 3
- Many of the mobile home parks are in District 2 and 3
- Total Deviation – 3.4%
Draft Map: Plan X3
Draft Plan X3 was developed based on Commission and community feedback and will be reviewed by the 2021 Advisory Redistricting Commission on October 20, 2021 as part of Agenda Item 5, which will not be heard before 7:00 pm. Html version of the map which allows for zooming in. Highlights of this plan include:
- A majority-minority API District 3, with Sunnyvale whole within it
- Uniting Milpitas with Berryessa in District 3
- Los Gatos & Monte Sereno moved into District 5 with Palo Alto and Mountain View, out of the southern district
- San José removed from District 5 - the eastern district
- The northern and southern API communities within San José not connected
- The City of Santa Clara whole
- Total Deviation – 8.2%
Draft Map: Maptitude Unity Draft Plan
Maptitude Unity Draft Plan was developed based on Communities of Interest Testimony Nos. 51 and 52 (https://districtr.org/plan/63279) and will be reviewed by the 22021 Advisory Redistricting Commission on October 20, 2021 as part of Agenda Item 5, which will not be heard before 7:00 pm. Html version of the map which allows for zooming in. Highlights of the plan include:
- Uniting Milpitas, Sunnyvale and Berryessa together in District 3, creating a 48.6% Citizen Voting Age Population (CVAP) API seat
- Uniting the City of Santa Clara with Campbell and western San José
- Creating a central San José seat in District 2 that’s 41.6% CVAP Latino and 32.4% CVAP API
- Los Gatos & Monte Sereno moved into District 5 with Palo Alto and Mountain View, out of the southern district
- Total Deviation – 8.4%
DRAFT REDISTRICTING PLANS REVIEWED BY THE 2021 ADVISORY COMMISSION
October 13, 2021
Based on the Commissioner discussion and direction at the October 3, 2021 Advisory Redistricting Commission meeting, the following maps were presented for consideration to be recommended to the Board of Supervisors:
- Draft Plan X
- Draft Plan Y
- Draft Plan Z
Draft Map: Plan X
Plan X was developed based on Communities of Interest Testimony and reviewed by the 2021 Advisory Redistricting Commission on October 13, 2021 at 6:30 pm. Enlargeable version of Draft Plan X. Based on feedback received on this draft, Redistricting Partners developed Draft Plan X2 and X3.
Draft Map: Plan Y
Plan Y was developed based on Communities of Interest Testimony and reviewed by the Advisory Redistricting Commission on October 13, 2021 at 6:30 pm. Enlargeable version.
Draft Map: Plan Z
Plan Z utilizes the current Supervisorial District lines as a guide and was reviewed by the 2021 Advisory Redistricting Commission on October 13, 2021 at 6:30 pm. Enlargeable version.